The
concept and driving force behind Twitter is microblgging. The character
restriction on Twitter is a factor that helps differentiate it from other forms
of social networking. Given that the user is restricted to 140 characters,
largely influences what is updated, communicated and shared. I think this
character restriction has shaped and defined what Twitter has become - an
immense feed of short posts which are largely personal, that have also tools
for marketing and communication.
Twitter
can be whatever we make of it because there are no rules; it depends on what
the user uses it for as well as how. Thus, in comparison with a
Blackboard discussion Twitter is fairly different. Twitter discussions
are quick, receiving constant tweets. A mere keyword or question can
generate responses from numerous users. On the other hand, Blackboard discussions
are more structured in which users post comments or answers to questions via
threads. Other users can comment on a thread through another thread and
so on. These threads are not limited to 140 characters, and because of
this the discussions do not have the quickness or continuity of
simple responses that Twitter discussions do. Discussions on Blackboard
are limited to certain users; because of this there is no opportunity of
missing a threaded response like there is on Twitter given its public nature.
Despite this, I think Blackboard conversations are probably more profound
and meaningful. Now, I recognize al the benefits and new uses for
Twitter, and may very well change my mind as the course progresses and begin to
use Twitter myself. However, as of now I think Blackboard conversations,
despite its rigid structure and interface, is better for discussing and
expressing well thought out thoughts. Twitter, on the other hand, is best
at inviting others to pitch in on a short tweet.
I
think that discussions in class and Twitter have more common ground than the
previous forms did. Discussions via these methods incite sporadic
contributions and expression of ideas. Of course, certain elements like
actual face-to-face interaction is not plausible via Twitter, yet, I think
Twitter achieves the same, if not more richness in discussions because of the
nature of tweets. However, like Blackboard discussions, in class ones are
limited to those present. Of course meaningful exchange will occur and
ideas will be communicated and developed. Yet, it simply will not be
completely open to the millions of users Twitter has. This, however, I
believe is one great aspect of Twitter; the ability to search a topic of
interest or keyword and tweet away with others tweeting the same topic is
limitless. Moreover, like the article "50 Ways to Use Twitter in the College Classroom" states, Twitter offers new ways to open lines of communication. Twitter is so rich in access that it facilitates collaboration and brainstorming. The article "Professor Encourages Students to Pass Notes During Class- via Twitter" offers an innovative way to communicate in the classroom. This takes in class discussions a step further because tweets are encouraged during class and can being up new discussions resulting from questions students may fear asking or posted links. Thus, new discussions are prompted and enriched in class.
Overall I believe that what differentiates Twitter from
Blackboard and in class discussions is the content of what is exchanged.
Given the different forms of communicating the three have, so to does the
content. Maybe Twitter and Blackboard discussions lack fact to face
interaction whereas in class ones don't. However each is strong in its
own way because it has strengths that are particular to the medium that it is.
I'm new to Twitter as well and I think that the power it has can be life changing, just like the way it helped to land a plane. I do think that Twitter can revolutionize the learning experience in a classroom if utilized properly. I agree that Blackboard allows for more in depth flow of ideas, but from my experience, it has been hard to keep up with who posted or responded to what because you have to keep manually checking, something that Twitter has easily compiled into a single place. As for in-class discussions, I think they are a valuable way of learning that can never be replaced. Twitter and Blackboard are just tools that build upon a classroom experience where more people are able to share their thoughts and ideas.
ReplyDelete